Tuesday, December 28, 2021

Violet's Immigrant Family and Her Brooklyn Childhood thru College

This is the second in my "Virtual Sitting Shiva" series of Blog postings of memories of Violet (Stark) Glickstein, my dear wife of 57 years, who sadly passed away November 27, 2021. [The first posting in this series is Here]

The photo below shows Violet, as a child, with her younger brother Sam, and their mother, Clara Stark. (In the early 1950's, when his photo was taken, none of us knew Violet and I would marry, and Clara would become my Mother-in-Law!) 





A CHILD OF IMMIGRANTS

Violet was born and raised in Brooklyn, NY. She was proud of her Hungarian heritage and membership in the Jewish community. Both of her parents were born in Hungary. 

In 1938, recognizing the existential threat to the Jewish community posed by the growing Nazi menace, her parents-to-be separately immigrated to the United States. The following year, in September 1939, Hitler invaded Poland.  

The image below is of the Hungarian passport issued to Violet's father, Geza Stark, in 1938. 




The "Declaration of Intention" document pictured below was filed in New York in 1940. It gives Geza's birthplace as "Pazab", Hungary. [I could not find "Pazab" on a current map of Hungary. "Pazab" may be a typographical error, or an alternate spelling. Google found a town in north-eastern Hungary called "Paszab".]

Geza's date of birth is given as January 9, 1914. His height is 5 feet 4 inches, and he weighs in at 125 pounds. He came to the US on the vessel Washington on April 1, 1938. He pledges to "renounce forever all allegiance and fidelity to any foreign prince, potentate, state or sovereignty". 

Geza's occupation is simply listed as "Tailor". That is a bit of an understatement because, in the 1960's, he went on to become a well-known custom tailor with a shop on Broadway in Manhattan, He Americanized his given name, "Geza", to "Gilbert".

His famous customers included a fellow-Hungarian, Edward Teller, the well-known theoretical physicist who is colloquially referred to as "the father of the hydrogen bomb". See Edward Teller - Wikipedia. When Teller came to New York to be measured and fitted for his custom-tailored suits, he enjoyed relaxing and conversing in his native language with a fellow Hungarian Jew.  

When Violet grew up and heard about her dad's friendship with the famous physicist, she asked if Gilbert had ever requested and received an autograph. "The only autograph I needed from him," answered Gilbert, "was on his check paying for the suits."


CLARA AND GILBERT MARRY

In 1940, Gilbert met and married a fellow Hungarian Jewish immigrant named Clara Schwartz, who had come to the US with her mother, Julia Schwartz. Although Clara and Gilbert arrived in the same year, 1938, they travelled on separate ships. They did not know each other until they met in New York. 

Clara and Gilbert's wedding photo, below, shows them with Clara's mother, Julia, and her second husband, Samuel Schwartz. (Julia's first husband, whose last name was Katz, was killed in Hungary before she and Clara immigrated to the US in 1938.) 


Violet was born on April 27, 1942, five months after the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor. Gilbert joined the US Army. He was sent to England, where he trained for the eventual allied invasion of Europe that started in June of 1944. He did not talk much about his wartime experiences, but we know he rose to the rank of Seargent. The photo below shows Gilbert in uniform with Clara and Violet. 

 



VIOLET'S EDUCATION IN BROOKLYN, NY

Violet's family were observant, Orthodox Jews. At an early age, her grandmother, Julia, taught her to recite the Hebrew prayers. They were serious about attended Saturday services nearly every week. Violet often recounted the fun she had as a young child at synagogue.

My family, also ostensibly Orthodox Jewish, had nearly zero literal religious belief and was almost totally non-observant. We considered Jewish religious services to be a boring waste of time. Sure, if the 13-year-old son of a relative or neighbor was being Bar Mitzvah, and we were invited, we would attend. But mainly as a matter of duty and obligation.

We considered ourselves to be loyal, red-blooded Americans. We had no desire to leave the US and move to the newly established Jewish State of Israel. Yet, we wanted Israel to be strong economically and militarily. We contributed to Jewish charities that helped Israel. We voted for candidates who favored continued American support for Israel. 

As you may know, in an Orthodox synagogue, men sit in the front, women in the rear, behind a partition called the "Mechitzah". (As it was explained to me, this seating arrangement is not degrading to the honor and dignity of women. It is necessary to allow men to give their full attention and concentration to their prayers, which is possible only if their eyes are shielded from seeing women's bodies.  Apparently, this is not a problem for women looking at men's bodies.) 

Observant Jews, like Violet's grandmother, actually enjoy the hours they devote to Saturday religious services. Violet repeatedly told me how much fun she had as a small child attending services most Saturday mornings with her grandmother. Young girls, and boys, would generally sit in the women's section with their mothers and grandmothers. We all know that there is a limit to a small child's "sitzfleisch" (Yiddish word meaning something like "sitting on your butt flesh".) Therefore, according to Violet's happy memories, she and other kids would get out of their seats and run from the woman's section out the back door, around to the front of the synagogue, and back in through the men's section! 

When an Orthodox Jewish boy reaches the age of 13, he is eligible to be Bar Mitzvah, the precept or commandment, and associated religious initiation ceremony, confirming he is ready to observe religious precepts and take part in public worship. Even though my family was not particularly religiously observant, I, as a male, was expected to learn to read Hebrew well enough to recite the major prayers and be Bar Mitzvah. Therefore, starting a few years before I turned 13, I attended Hebrew School for a couple hours on Sunday, and  for an hour on two weekdays. after elementary school let out.

Obedient to a fault, I did my part. I learned to recite the prayers and chant my Haftorah in Hebrew. (A Haftorah is a reading, from the book of Prophets, which is different every week.) On my appointed Bar Mitzvah Saturday, a couple dozen members of my proud family (mostly from Brooklyn but including at least two relatives from the Bronx) joined over 100 regular Sabbath attendees at the Hebrew Alliance Synagogue in Brighton Beach to witness my performance

Near the end of the service, in my squeaky, not-yet-fully-mature voice, I gave the expected "Today I am a man" speech to the crowd. 

Later that day, my parents hosted a grand reception and dinner party for invited family and friends at a nearby catering hall. There was lots of food, an open bar with (mostly) responsible drinking, and loud music and dancing. Midway through the event, I was asked to get up and repeat my speech. A family friend who had access to a movie camera captured highlights of the event on film and audiotape.  

VIOLET'S FACILITY WITH LANGUAGE

Violet has always been better than me at reading Hebrew. She also seems to have a knack for learning words and phrases from other languages that we've encountered on our travels, including Arabic, Greek, French, Spanish, Italian, Russian, and even Chinese. 

Like many immigrant families, Violet's parents, Clara and Gilbert, and her grandparents, Julia and Samuel, spoke their native language at home, to the near exclusion of English. 

One of Violet's favorite stories is how, when she started attending the neighborhood public elementary school, her mother was called in by her teacher. The teacher suggested that they speak English at home because "it will be good for both of you." I don't know how that type of frank (and in my opinion good) advice would go over in today's political climate, but they accepted and followed it. 


VIOLET'S HIGH SCHOOL AND COLLEGE YEARS


Violet graduated from Lafayette High School in June 1959, intending to "major in science and math [at] Brooklyn College."


No surprise! In 1963, Violet graduated from Brooklyn College with a Bachelor's degree in Science. She was a member of the Chemistry Society, Lowell House, and the Yiddish Club.




So, please join me in thinking about your good and eventful times with Violet. Read subsequent postings on this Blog about events I remember. If you'd like, you could put on some slippers, sit on your couch, and join me and others in a "virtual" Shiva for Violet.

Love to all, and specially elevated kisses and hugs to Violet, from her husband,



Ira Glickstein



NOTE:  This is the second of our "Virtual Sitting Shiva", the traditional Jewish custom of relatives and friends devoting seven days to specially remembering the deceased.

Violet and Ira Glickstein were married in 1964. See our 50th Anniversary memories in the following postings include highlights of our life together.

CLICK THE HYPERTEXT BELOW TO JUMP TO YOUR TOPIC OF CHOICE

  1. Wedding and Farm Days 
  2. Passing the Genes and Memes
  3. Computers R Us (Ira and Vi's careers)
  4. Retirement in The Villages, FL
  5. Our 50th Anniversary Baltic Cruise (Air Travel and Shipboard activities)
  6. Our 50th Anniversary Baltic Cruise (Land-Tours)

50th-0 CELEBRATING OUR 50th WEDDING ANNIVERSARY (tvpclub.blogspot.com)















Monday, December 27, 2021

One Year Ago Today My Dear Wife Violet Passed Away


Today marks one month since the sad passing, late Saturday evening, November 27, 2021, of my beloved wife of 57 years, Violet (Stark) Glickstein, age 79. 

In addition to being a special blessing to me as my wife, Violet was also a devoted mother to our three children, Lisa, Rena, and Sara; and a loving grandmother to Lisa's children (Alex, Michela, and Samantha) and Sara's (Isaac and Emerson). Violet was also a great friend to many others. 

HOW WE WILL REMEMBER AND HONOR VIOLET


We, as a family, will remember Violet for all the great times we had together. Education was important to her, and she delighted in family events at our children's and grandchildren's elementary and high schools. 

Advanced education, at the College and Post-Graduate levels, was particularly significant. Violet and I "kvelled" (Yiddish word meaning "burst with pride") as our children were awarded the degrees they had earned (PhDs for Lisa and Sara, a Masters for Rena, and Bachelors for Lisa's children). 

Speaking of degrees, Violet earned her Bachelors in Chemistry in 1963 (not the norm for females in the 1960's). Once our children were out of elementary school, Violet went back to college to earn her Masters in Computer Science (1983), when in her 40's! (With all those advanced degrees flying around in our immediate family, I felt "obligated" to get my Masters and PhD while in my very ripe 50's!)

In addition to delighting in education, Violet loved to travel with me, family members, and friends. At or near the top of her list of favorite places in the world were destinations with "Disney" in their titles: Disneyland (California), Disney World (Florida), and even Shanghai Disney Resort (China). We visited the latter in 2017, when our Grandchild Michaela, a Hospitality Major at Purdue, was doing an internship at a Chinese resort, see The Virtual Philosophy Club: Beyond Communism - the Emergence of a Newly Prosperous and Increasingly Capitalist CHINA! (tvpclub.blogspot.com) and The Virtual Philosophy Club: CHINA - WAY BEYOND COMMUNISM (tvpclub.blogspot.com)

We also travelled to England when our Grandchild Alex was interning at Oxford. We would have visited our third Grandchild Samantha when she was interning, however, she was in Australia, so far off the grid that a visit was not possible. 

Other family vacations included our Alaska cruise in 2010, where Violet showed she still had lots of "zip" in her as we flew between trees riding the zipline in Ketchican, see The Virtual Philosophy Club: Plenty of ZIP as We Mature (tvpclub.blogspot.com) 





From left to right sitting around the table: Michaela Hagler, Jerry Hagler, Alex Hagler, David Moyers, Rena Moyers, Lisa Glickstein, Samantha Hagler, Violet Glickstein. I (Ira) am standing in the rear with Lou who lives on the cruise ship.

In 2014 we took the family on a Baltic cruise that included a brief stop in St. Petersberg, Russia, see: The Virtual Philosophy Club: Our Brief Visit to Russia (tvpclub.blogspot.com) 

As we waited in the St. Petersburg park, along with our Grandchild Alex, I noticed the pigeons had an unusual fondness for the famous Russian writer, see photos above. I tested my ability to sound out Cyrillic characters by reading the inscription on the Pushkin statue, "Алекса́ндр Серге́евич ПУШК" [ALEKSANDER SERGEVITCH PUSHKIN].


VIOLET'S OBITUARY

Our daughter Lisa composed a marvelous obituary that captures the essence of Violet. Violet Glickstein | Obituaries | thevillagesdailysun.com



VIRTUALLY "SITTING SHIVA" FOR VIOLET

According to Wikipedia, Shiva (Hebrew: שבעה‎‎, literally "seven") is the week-long mourning period for first-degree relatives. The ritual is referred to as "sitting shiva". According to Jewish law, we assume the status of "avel" (Hebrew: אבל; "mourner"). This state lasts for seven days, during which family members traditionally gather and receive visitors.

In our modern times, when families live all over the US and the World, and where literal belief is scarce, it isn't really practical for first-degree relations to sit around on couches in the living room for a week wearing slippers.

Although I lack any real literal belief in Jewish ritual, IMHO, it does make sense for those closest to the deceased to make a special effort to remember her (at least) during the weeks and months following her departure.

For reasons I can't defend rationally, I'm very pleased that our daughters Lisa, Rena, and Sara, and Lisa's children, Alex, Michaela, and Samantha attended Hebrew school, learned to read that ancient language, and went through the formal Bat Mitzvah process. I don't think any of them had then or have now any real literal belief, which, in a way, makes it a sort of minor miracle that they did so. (This last sentence brings tears to my eyes as 
I read it. How about you?)



VIOLET'S HEROIC STRUGGLE WITH LIVER DISEASE

For several months prior to her passing, Violet and I were concerned about the damage diabetes had wrought on her liver. Several months ago, on September 14, 2021, Dr. Eric Schwartzberg attempted to perform a TIPS procedure at the Leesburg Hospital (see Transjugular intrahepatic portosystemic shunt - Wikipedia) to place a shunt near her liver, and his attempt failed due to "occlusions" in the portal vein. 

Prior to the surgery, the doctor was quite frank with us. He said he had done dozens of successful TIPS procedures where there were no occlusions. Unfortunatey, he said, he has attempted six with occlusions, and only two of them were successful. "So, I'll be number three!" said Violet confidently. Sadly, the odds were against her, and they won.

A week after the failed TIPS procedure, Violet fell in our apartment, and I could not get her back up on her feet. The staff at Freedom Pointe Independent Living called 911 and the very prompt and efficient EMTs showed up and took her to the Emergency Room at The Villages Hospital. After two weeks of treatment at the hospital, she was released to the skilled nursing "Rehab" facility on the Freedom Pointe campus. 

Unfortunately, after a few days at Rehab, she falls there, perhaps due to low blood pressure, and is readmitted to the hospital. She cycled from hospital to Rehab and back again three times as the doctors tried to find a mixture of drugs and treatments to balance her body chemistry against the buildup of toxins caused by her liver failure. Due to Covid restrictions, each time Violet was admitted to FP Rehab, she had to be isolated, and visitors were required to wear full Personal Protective Equipment. The photo shows Lisa and me in full-PPE. 

VIOLET COMES HOME FOR HER FINAL WEEK

Finally, on Tuesday, November 16, Violet was returned to our Independent Living apartment and was able to eat in our Dining Room. 

Looking back, what turned out to be her final week at home (November 16th thru 23rd) was a glorious time! 

Vi was warmly greeted by everyone each day that we ate our big meal of the day in the Dining Room, and as we passed through other public areas.

Freedom Pointe has been proactive in the Covid-19 crisis. They scheduled on-site clinics in January and February where both Vi and I were fully vaccinated with Pfizer shots. They had an on-site clinic in October, where I got my booster shot. Vi missed that clinic because she was off-site, but, when she was back home on November 18th, I drove her to our Publix pharmacy, and she was boosted.

On Sunday, November 21, one of the last days of that most wonderful week, our good friends Bunny and Bob Adler took us on a tour of the Fenney Springs Nature Trail in The Villages. 

Vi sat comfortably in her wheeled transport chair as we pushed her along the paved trail, enjoying the birds, turtles, fish, and a sleepy alligator. Earlier, we had stopped by a fast-food place and picked up the Chicken Sandwich Vi had begged for all through her Hospital/Rehab confinement. We consumed our chicken and fries in the shade of tall trees.



VIOLET'S FINAL DAYS

A few days later, Wednesday, November 24, Violet and I were scheduled for an early morning visit to the nearby LabCorp to give fasting-blood samples. She woke me about 5am, and, using her walker with a bit of help from me, was able to make a successful visit to the toilet. She woke me again around 6am and puked up a bit of the Blackened Catfish she had consumed at the Freedom Pointe Dining Room the evening before. 

As 7am departure time for our LabCorp journey approached, Violet was unable to stand up, so I went myself. 

When I returned, she was sleeping atop the covers on her bed. She woke-up and was communicative, but lethargic and a bit confused, I called the Freedom Pointe nurse who came right away. She examined Violet and took her Blood Pressure which was low. We used her Libre Blood Sugar sensor and got a moderately high reading. 

The nurse called 911. Those dependable EMTs showed up, checked her vitals, and asked a series of questions, which Violet answered in a confused manner. 

When I got to the Emergency Room (ER) Violet was getting her CT-Scan. When she was wheeled back into her ER room, her eyes were partially open, but she was non-communicative. 

The ER nurses and doctors informed me that Violet was in critical condition, with multiple system failures, including not only her liver, but kidneys as well. They suggested she should be given only "comfort care". She was transferred from the ER to the Intensive Care Unit (ICU).

I checked the "Living Will" documents that she and I had updated in recent months, and, after Lisa spoke directly to the nurse and the doctor, and we all agreed, I signed the papers necessary to place her in "Comfort care" status.

Violet remained unresponsive to spoken requests from me that she move her tongue or move her hand when it is being squeezed. Her eyes remained partially open, pupils slowly scanning side to side, as Lisa, via speakerphone "talked" to her, as did our son-in-law Jerry and one of our grandchildren, Alex. 

The following day, friends Bunny and Bob drove me to visit Violet in the ICU and we set up her transfer to the Cornerstone Hospice. 

The image above, taken on Wednesday, November 24th by our good friend Bunny Adler in The Villages Hospital ICU, is the last photo of Violet and me together. 

Violet was admitted to Cornerstone Hospice the following day, November 25th.

On Friday, November 26, Rabbi Zev of Temple Shalom (where Violet and I are founding members) met and comforted me at Hospice, He spoke to Violet and said the appropriate prayers. I went to Friday services that evening at Temple Shalom. 

On Saturday, November 27, Bunny and Bob drove me to the beautiful, tree-shaded Hillcrest Memorial Gardens, in nearby Leesburg, to select the plot where Violet was to be buried, and the adjacent plot reserved for me. 

Our plots are in the Jewish "Garden of David" area near the Temple Shalom Memorial Garden.

The photo below shows the plots reserved for Violet and me (green flags).


Violet was interred on December 2, in a private ceremony conducted by Rabbi Zev. 


AFTERWORD

Earlier this week, after a pleasant dinner in the Freedom Pointe Pub with good friends, I picked up my mail and got in the elevator to go back up to my apartment. A couple of fellow residents, who I don’t happen to know very well, popped into the elevator just as the doors were about to close. “Sorry for your loss” they said, in a sincere effort to acknowledge Vi’s passing and comfort me.

 

“This will be my first New Years without her,” I replied. Tears came to my eyes. I had difficulty completing that sentence. 


I think of myself as a relatively non-emotional man who treats the difficulties of life and human interaction with the same cold logic and precise engineering I devoted to the solution of System Engineering issues!


Not so!

 

Vi’s critical illness and relatively sudden departure from this world have been extremely difficult for me. Yes, friends and relatives have come through for me with sincere kindness and have been extremely generous with their time. 


Rabbi Zev and leaders and members of Temple Shalom have been wonderful. 


The staff and medical professionals at Freedom Pointe Independent Living and Rehab and The Villages Hospital have been warm and gracious. 


Our daughter Lisa, sons-in-law Jerry and David, and our triplet grands Alex, Michaela, and Samantha disrupted their very active working lives to come here in person to comfort and help me, and, to clean up the clutter in our apartment. They each continue to support me via cellphone and internet.


CELEBRATING CHANUKAH 2021 FOR VIOLET

Vi's passing coincided with our celebration of Chanukah in the Freedom Pointe lobby. The photo below shows some of our fellow residents, along with visiting family members, kindling the Chanukah lights for the fourth day.

They are (left to right): 

[Fellow Residents] Lynn Belford, Roy Belford, Roben Gaftman, Bob Adler, Marty Rothbard, Bunny Adler,

[Family] Samantha Hagler (Grandchild), Jerry Hagler (Son-in-law), Alex Hagler (Grandchild), Michaela Hagler (Grandchild), David Moyers (Son-in-law), Lisa Glickstein (Daughter), and, in the Chanukah-themed "I LATKE, MOVE IT, MOVE IT" shirt, me, Ira Glickstein.


So, please join me in thinking about your good and eventful times with Violet. Read subsequent postings on this Blog about events I remember. If you'd like, you could put on some slippers, sit on your couch, and join me and others in a "virtual" Shiva for Violet.

Love to all, and specially elevated kisses and hugs to Violet, from her husband,



Ira Glickstein


Violet and Ira Glickstein were married in 1964. See our 50th Anniversary memories in the following postings include highlights of our life together.

CLICK THE HYPERTEXT BELOW TO JUMP TO YOUR TOPIC OF CHOICE

  1. Wedding and Farm Days 
  2. Passing the Genes and Memes
  3. Computers R Us (Ira and Vi's careers)
  4. Retirement in The Villages, FL
  5. Our 50th Anniversary Baltic Cruise (Air Travel and Shipboard activities)
  6. Our 50th Anniversary Baltic Cruise (Land-Tours)

50th-0 CELEBRATING OUR 50th WEDDING ANNIVERSARY (tvpclub.blogspot.com)


NOTE:  This is the first of our "Virtual Sitting Shiva", the traditional Jewish custom of relatives and friends devoting seven days to specially remembering the deceased.

Sunday, August 8, 2021

CHINA - WAY BEYOND COMMUNISM


Left: Ira at Shanghai Disney with four of my favorite women, my wife Vi, oldest daughter Lisa, and one of our triplet grands, Michaela, a Hospitality major at Purdue University, who was doing a six-month internship at a Chinese resort. Right: Vi in Tiananmen Square under the portrait of Mao Tse Tung, whose visage appears on Chinese currency.

I presented "CHINA WAY BEYOND COMMUNISM" to an interactive audience at The Villages (Florida) Philosophy Club on August 6th 2021. My talk is an updated version of the one I gave nearly four-years ago to both the Philosophy Club and the S.K.I.L.L. Club (CIA retirees). See: Beyond Communism - the Emergence of a Newly Prosperous and Increasingly Capitalist CHINA! (tvpclub.blogspot.com)

Much has changed since our China visit four years ago. 

Chinese leader Xí Jìnpíng is more firmly in control. The two-term limit on the presidency has been removed so he may remain the Chinese leader for life. 

China's one-child policy has been revised to allow -even encourage- two children (or even three). This is in response to an ageing of the Chinese population and a growing gender imbalance. When limited to only a single child, Chinese parents favored male children by disproportionally aborting females. 

Hong Kong and Taiwan are under increasing pressure to unify with the mainland. 

Chinese military and economic control of the South China Sea area is progressing faster than ever. 

Also, the COVID-19 pandemic, which spread world-wide since it originated in China in 2019, seems most likely to have been an accidental leak from the Wuhan Institute of Virology, rather than from Wuhan's "wet markets".


Key Question

Might the Chinese model of a Single Political Party Ruling over a nearly Uniform population (92% ethnic Han Chinese)

eventually prove to be superior to the Western-Democratic model of 

Two (or more) Political Parties Dueling over a Diverse population (which celebrates ethnic and racial differences)?


Flash-Back to 1958 and 19-year-old Ira

Way back in 1958, when I was 19-years old and a sophomore engineering student at City College of New York, I had a Letter to the Editor published in "the newspaper of record", the New York Times. 

As you may recall, the Chinese Communist Party, under the leadership of Mao Tse Tung, had established the People's Republic of China on the mainland, and chased the Nationalists, under the leadership of Chiang Kai Shek, to off-shore islands, mainly the island of Taiwan and the city of Hong Kong.

My letter was a response to the opinions expressed by JAMES WARBURG (1896-1969), a  German-born American Banker, former financial adviser to President Franklin D. Roosevelt, who helped to found the Washington-based Institute for Policy Studies. Warburg was a member of the Council on Foreign Relations.

Warburg had called for the United States to evacuate the Nationalist leadership from Taiwan to avoid further conflict with the People's Republic of China. The US President at that time was Dwight D. Eisenhower. We continued our support for the Chinese Nationalists. Warburg wrote that the actions of President Eisenhower in both the Far East and Middle East were "almost inconceivable" and "irresponsible".

Here is my letter as it appeared in The New York Times on September 10, 1958. NOTE: I used the Portuguese name "Formosa" (meaning "Beautiful Island"). That usage fell out of favor in the 1960's. when reading my letter, please substitute "Taiwan" for "Formosa".



I'm particularly proud of the final sentence in my letter:

"The United States is the greatest country in the world and it is time we started acting that way."

Looking James Warburg up in Wikipedia, I found this quote from him favoring World Government: "We shall have world government, whether or not we like it. The question is only whether world government will be achieved by consent or by conquest." 

Well, if you favor world government, presumably on a "one person, one vote" basis, you have to understand that both China and India currently have populations more than four times that of  the US. 


The Key Question

Might the Chinese model of a Single Political Party Ruling over a nearly Uniform population (92% ethnic Han Chinese)

eventually prove to be superior to the Western-Democratic model of 

Two (or more) Political Parties Dueling over a Diverse population (which celebrates ethnic and racial differences)?



China's population is UNIFORM and UNITED - 92% ETHNIC HAN CHINESE. Their political system is MONOLITHIC - ONE PARTY RULES! 

The US population is DIVERSE and SPLIT along officially designated ethnic, racial, and national origin classifications.

(Read how, in the mid-1970's, I was sent on a recruitment trip to the University of Michigan by my employer, IBM Federal Systems, and was required to classify the engineering students I interviewed according to their gender, race, and national origin. Why Politically Correct Racism and Sexism is Evil. I was not allowed to ask the students who applied for possible employment by IBM what their gender, race, and national origin was, nor was I allowed to inform them that a computer record was going to  be made of my classification. Furthermore, I was told I could invite students for an expense-paid trip to our facility in Owego, NY only if they had a specific GPA or more, unless they were a "minority" or female, in which case I could invite them if they appeared qualified, even if their GPA was below the specified number. I also discovered, on that recruiting trip, that some manager at IBM had classified me - and presumably all my fellow employees - by race, national origin, and gender, without informing us!) 

The US is officially about 60% "White - non-Hispanic". Of course, this 60% includes people who identify with many different countries of national origin (Germany, England, Ireland, Italy, France, Poland, Holland, Scotland, ... and so, on and on) but the government has singled-out only those with "Hispanic Surnames" for special treatment. 

Our population is about 19% "Brown - Hispanic Surname". It is about 13% "Black" or "African", and about 6% "Asian". 


THE PLACES IN CHINA WE VISITED - AND THOSE WE DIDN'T VISIT


As the above map indicates, we flew from the USA to Hong Kong in September 2017. Never leaving the Hong Kong airport, we boarded a plane to Beijing. (The total trip, from our home in Florida to the Orlando airport, changing planes in San Francisco, again in Hong Kong, and the trip from Beijing airport to our hotel, took 36 hours! The time in China is exactly 12 hours different from that in Florida! So, 12 Noon in China is 12 Midnight in Florida!

We took what has become a more-or-less standard tour, spending a few days in each of a few business and tourist cities: Beijing, Xian, and Shanghai. Since our granddaughter  Michaela, a Hospitality major at Purdue University, was doing a six-month internship at a Chinese resort in Suzhou, we added a couple of days to our trip to spend time with her, and with her mother (our daughter Lisa) who was on a separate trip to China.

We did not visit three areas: The city of Wuhan, the province of Xinjang, and the nation of Taiwan:

WUHAN: Looking at the above map, you may see the now-infamous Chinese city of Wuhan at the very center of the four cities we visited. Indeed, we flew near Wuhan twice! Of course we had no idea that Wuhan, in late 2019, would become the point of origin for the COVID-19 pandemic. 

XINJANG: Note the warning on the map that the far west provinces shown in yellow, including Xinjang, were places where visitors should "Exercise a high degree of caution". That area is where a racial minority, the Uyghurs, a Turkic people, live, and are not treated well by Chinese authorities. 

TAIWAN: The subject of my 1958 Letter to the Editor of The New York Times was not visited. Perhaps we'll get there on some future trip. Of course, I am pleased that Taiwan is not under control of mainland China. Both China and Taiwan agree that they will -eventually- be reunited under the "One country, two systems for Hong Kong and Macau, with a future of complete national reunification, (one-China policy) with Taiwan." I hope that happens, but only after the mainland Chinese adopt a political and economic system more like that of the Western Democracies. 


CHINA POSES AN ECONOMIC THREAT TO THE US AND OTHER "WESTERN DEMOCRACIES"


The above graphic shows that China, as of 2021, has developed an economic lead over the United States in Gross Domestic Product (GDP). There are several ways to compute GDP and China is still a bit behind the US when "nominal" GDP is calculated using official exchange rates. However, considering the "Purchasing Power Parity" (PPP) method, based on the actual relative cost of local goods, they are ahead. 

Of course, with a total population that is over four times that of the US, so the PER-CAPITA PPP-GDP (shown in RED in the above graphic) of the US is still more than three times that of China.


What Does the Future Hold?

I am a optimist - but, now at the age of 82, also a realist. 

I wish the best for China - our tour guides and everyone we met there were kind and capable and helpful to two elderly visitors (75 and 78 at that time). 

I hope they will continue their remarkable development of emergent prosperity and increasingly Capitalistic economics. On the other hand, I'm worried that their increasingly hostile attitude towards Hong Kong and Taiwan may lead them to use military force to impose their "one-China policy".

Furthermore, their treatment of the Uyghur minorities may turn out to be a model for possible imposition of Chinese sovereignty over much of Southeast Asia.   

In 2017, they added “Xi Jinping Thought on Socialism with Chinese Characteristics for a New Era” to their constitution. The following three items caught my attention: 

        “Socialism with Chinese characteristics" with "people as the masters of the country".

        Governing China with the rule of law.

        “Socialist core values", Marxism, Communism … “Socialism with Chinese characteristics".

 Note the repeated phrase “Socialism with Chinese Characteristics”

What is that, actually? I think it might be summarized in one word: "CAPITALISM!"

Let us review Chinese history on this issue. 

-        1978 – Mao Tse Tung died and Deng Xiaoping introduced "market socialism."

-        "Four Modernizations", agriculture, industry, science-technology, military.

-        "A planned economy is not the definition of socialism, because there is planning under capitalism; the market economy happens under socialism, too. Planning and market forces are both ways of controlling economic activity".

-        1982 Constitution - Civil rights: free speech, press, worship, the right to trial, and the right to own private property.

-        Rights NOT widely followed in practice, but people with connections to the socialist economy have been able to “own” apartments (70-year lease)

-        Widespread Computer, Internet, Cellphone usage - BUT serious issues with censorship,  …

Of course, Classical Marxists will Object to “Socialism with Chinese Characteristics” as it begins to look more and more like Capitalism. They will say:

        A "socialist market economy" is contradictory!

        True Marxists say what China has  amounts to a full-blown capitalist economic system. [Not YET ‘full-blown” but getting there :^)]

        Although many enterprises are nominally publicly owned, the profits are retained by the enterprises and used to pay managers excessively high salaries rather than being distributed amongst the population.

        But, never mind, China (and former USSR) are in a “preliminary stage of socialism”.

        True Marxism will come when production increases to  the point that resources are virtually unlimited, then true Communism will emerge! 


CONCLUSION

I have great hopes that our children and grandchildren will live in a United States that continues to be economically prosperous and successful in a world with serious ECONOMIC competition, but highly restrained MILITARY competition. However, if it comes to the later, I expect the United States to continue our leadership. As I wrote 63 years ago, when I was 19 years old, in my Letter to the Editor of The New York Times:

"The United States is the greatest country in the world and it is time we started acting that way."


Love to all, Ira Glickstein


Sunday, June 14, 2020

Celebrating Flag Day 2020


Flag Day 2020 marks our 56th Wedding Anniversary. Vi and I were married on June 14th 1964, so each Flag Day celebration has special meaning for us.

The serious part of this posting is in three parts: 1) Three current crises, 2) Three patriotic songs, and 3) Three positive hopeful predictions.

But first, before we get to the serious part, let's have a look at:

MY FLAG DAY NEEDLEPOINT




44 years ago, in 1976, I designed and made a needlepoint replica of the then-current United States 13c postage stamp (see the graphic below).

My intent was to honor the American Revolution Bicentennial, marking the 200th year of the American Republic, our great experiment in Representative Democracy.

My replica is true to the postage stamp and the original 13-star flag, except for the arrangement of the stars. Instead of a circle of 13 stars, I substituted 13 stars in a "Star of David" arrangement. This is like the 13 stars in the Great Seal of the United States that you have seen on the back of  the US dollar bill.





On the postage stamp shown above, Independence Hall is depicted in front of the flag, That also has meaning to Vi and me because we drove from Brooklyn to Philadelphia on the day I presented our engagement ring to her.

Monday, February 10, 2020

The MIRACULOUS Return of My "Darwin's Cathedral" Book


Is religion a useful biological "adaptation", as claimed by biologist David Sloan Wilson, author of the 2002 book Darwin's Cathedral - Evolution, Religion, and the Nature of Society, or is religion a "delusion" and a "mind virus", as claimed by biologist Richard Dawkins, author of the 2006 book The God Delusion ?   Or, as I claim, is religion BOTH a delusion and an adaptation?

This posting is about these two important books, but first, I must tell you the "miraculous" story of how, against all odds, I happened to get my copy of Darwin's Cathedral in the first place, how I stupidly lost that book, and the amazing story of how I got it back.

Sunday, November 17, 2019

Why Politically Correct Racism and Sexism is Evil


Presented to an enthusiastic audience at The Villages Philosophy Club on 22 November 2019.

Martin Luther King "I Have a Dream …"

In his famous 1963 speech, Martin Luther King said:
I have a dream that my four little children will one day live in a nation where they will not be judged by the color of their skin, but by the content of their character.” 
The 1964 Civil Rights Act, passed by a strong bi-partisan majority, 61% of Democrats (152-96) and 80% of Republicans (138-34) states: 
“all persons must be treated equally without regard to their race, color, or national origin.” 
In recent times, these noble American ideals (judge by character not skin color, and without regard  to race, color, or national origin) have been perverted by excessive regard for race, sex, nationality, gender, and other characteristics that have absolutely no bearing on the ability of any person to do any job. (An I have a DNA test that indicates I’m (hashtag) #NativeAmericanToo).